olives101OLIVE NEWS & INFORMATION 🇺🇸 🇫🇷
olives101 Sunday 15 November 2026
Health

Diet and Exercise Together Track Lower Alzheimer’s Risk

August 19, 2009 3 min read
A kitchen table laid with a tin of extra virgin olive oil, bowls of oranges, apples and pears, cherry tomatoes on the vine, fennel, red cabbage, carrots, garlic and a rustic loaf.
The pattern, not the pill: the trials tested a whole way of eating, with the oil doing its work alongside vegetables, pulses, fruit and fish.

A study of 1,880 older New Yorkers, published this month in JAMA, found that people who both ate a Mediterranean style diet and kept physically active had a lower rate of Alzheimer’s disease than people who did neither: about 12 percent over the study rather than 19 percent. It is the strongest version of a claim olive oil sellers love, which is exactly why it is worth reading slowly.

What the study did

The work comes from Columbia University Medical Center and appeared in the August 12 issue of JAMA. Researchers followed 1,880 people living in northern Manhattan who did not have dementia at the start, examining them roughly every 18 months between 1992 and 2006. Over an average of 5.4 years, 282 of them developed Alzheimer’s disease.

Each person was scored for how closely their eating matched a Mediterranean pattern, on a scale of 0 to 9, and separately for physical activity, weighted by how vigorous it was. The models were adjusted for the usual suspects: age, sex, ethnicity, education, the ApoE genotype, calorie intake, body mass index, smoking, depression, other leisure activity and existing illness.

Taken separately, both mattered. Compared with the lowest diet group, the highest had a hazard ratio of 0.60. Compared with people doing no physical activity, those doing much had a hazard ratio of 0.67. Taken together, the people scoring high on both had an absolute risk of 12 percent against 19 percent for those scoring low on both.

A second study in the same issue, from a French cohort of 1,410 people over 65 in Bordeaux, found that higher adherence to the Mediterranean diet went with slower decline on one cognitive test but not with a lower risk of dementia.

What it does not show

This is an observational study of self reported behavior, not a trial. Nobody was assigned a diet or a gym membership. The lead author said as much when the results came out, that only a randomized design would clarify the role of these behaviors, and the journal’s own editorial asked whether and how findings like these should be turned into advice to the public.

  • People who eat this way and exercise differ from people who do not in many ways the statistics cannot fully remove.
  • The diet score is a pattern, not a bottle. Fish, vegetables, legumes, fruit, cereals and monounsaturated fat in place of saturated fat, with modest meat and dairy.
  • The French study is a useful check: same pattern, different population, weaker result.

What olive oil contributes here is its role as the monounsaturated fat in that pattern, used instead of butter and lard rather than added on top of them. That is the honest claim, and it is the one we made when we explained what the Mediterranean diet actually is. The pattern has been linked to Alzheimer’s risk before, including in earlier work from the same New York cohort.

What a sensible person takes from it

Two habits, each associated with a lower rate of a disease nobody can currently treat well, and a bigger association when you have both. That is worth having. It is not a prescription, an insurance policy, or a reason to buy a more expensive bottle of oil.

If you want to act on it, the useful version is unglamorous: walk more, eat more vegetables, fish and legumes, use olive oil in place of butter rather than in addition to it, and keep the portion honest, because oil is dense in calories whatever else it does. This is general information, not medical advice. Anyone worried about memory, or about dementia risk in their family, should raise it with their doctor rather than with a shopping list.

What the sellers don’t tell you

Within a week of a study like this, the trade press turns a hazard ratio into a slogan and someone prints it on a label. Watch for the substitution trick: research on a whole dietary pattern gets sold as evidence for one product in it. The oil in these cohorts was ordinary kitchen olive oil used in place of other fats, not a premium bottle drunk by the spoonful.

Sources

Take this with you

The assistant links open with a question about this page already written.